Why desktop studies are not enough for nature-based solutions

Published: May 2026

A desktop study is a useful starting point. It is not a design tool.

In the world of nature-based solutions and SuDS design, there is a persistent tendency to treat remote data as sufficient — to produce strategies, reports, and even outline designs based entirely on maps, soil surveys, rainfall data, and topographic models. The results are often wrong, sometimes significantly so.

Here is why, and what to do about it.


What a desktop study actually gives you

A well-executed desktop study pulls together the best available remote data:

This data is genuinely valuable. It tells you roughly where water flows, what the general soil conditions might be, and where flooding has occurred in the past. It is the 10% of the picture that allows you to form a hypothesis before visiting a site.

The problem is treating that 10% as if it were 100%.


What remote data gets wrong

Soil maps are generalised. The BGS 1:50,000 geology layer and national soil surveys are mapped at a scale appropriate for regional planning, not site design. A field that appears as free-draining sandy loam on the map may have a clay pan 40cm below the surface that makes infiltration impossible. A field mapped as poorly-draining clay may have a network of old land drains that function perfectly well. You cannot know without digging.

Drainage records are incomplete. A significant proportion of drainage infrastructure in the UK — particularly in older urban areas and on private land — is not recorded on any accessible register. Culverted watercourses, informal field drains, private sewers, and historical drainage works regularly appear during site visits that were entirely absent from the desktop picture.

LiDAR misses micro-topography. Even high-resolution LiDAR (50cm or 1m) smooths out the small-scale ground features that determine where water actually flows and pools. A 20cm depression that will become a rain garden or the key overland flow path for a swale design can be invisible from the air and critical on the ground.

Vegetation changes everything. An area mapped as grassland may be heavily compacted by livestock, with near-zero infiltration. An area mapped as arable may have been left fallow and have excellent soil structure. The actual condition of vegetation and soil at the time of design matters enormously — and changes seasonally.

Catchment boundaries shift. Topographic catchment boundaries derived from terrain models assume water flows according to the surface. In practice, drainage infrastructure, buried culverts, and land management can redirect flows in ways that are invisible on a screen.


What a site visit reveals

A rigorous on-site investigation — carried out by someone who knows what they are looking for — closes the gap between the desktop hypothesis and reality.

In a typical 2–5 day site visit, we expect to discover:

These findings change designs. They change feasibility assessments. They change cost estimates. Sometimes they change the entire strategy.


The cost of getting it wrong

A SuDS design based on inaccurate infiltration data may fail at construction — when test pits reveal the soakaways will not work. The redesign costs money and causes delay.

A catchment restoration scheme based on incorrect drainage mapping may install leaky dams in the wrong locations — in channels that do not carry the flows assumed, while the real flow pathways remain untreated.

A planning application supported by a desk-based drainage strategy may be rejected or conditioned — because the drainage authority identifies uncertainties that a site investigation would have resolved.

In every case, the cost of the site visit is a fraction of the cost of getting the design wrong.


Our approach

Every project we take on begins with a Desktop Study + Site Visit package. The desktop phase shapes our hypotheses and our fieldwork programme. The site visit answers the questions the desktop cannot.

We do not produce NbS designs, SuDS strategies, or catchment restoration plans based on desk study alone. We will not be drawn into doing so, because the results would not be reliable — and our clients deserve reliable results.

If you have a site where the water cycle is not working as it should, contact us to discuss where to start.

← Back to Insights